Inactive WBS node

Hello fellow Pplanners,

I understand the purpose of making a project inactive; but, what about making inactive a WBS node when the whole project is active?

Thank you for any advice

Alexandre

Z
Zoltan Palffy 👤 Member for 16 years 10 months

ok that makes more sense dissolving an activitiy DELETES it and ites its predcessors to its successor it is gone so there is nothing to schedule. Making a wbs inactivity gives you the ablilty turn it off and on and make it park of the schedule  is you choose to.

A
Alexandre Faulx-Briole 👤 Member for 23 years 4 months

Zoltan,

I agree that "dissolve" an activity is not at all the same as "make a wbs node inactive"; what I mean is: a) when you make an wbs node inactive, P6 schedules the project as if the activities had been dissolved, or the same way as MS Project does with inactive taks; b) inactive wbs node can be re-activated, but dissolved activities cannot be restored.

Thank you for your help,

Alexandre

Z
Zoltan Palffy 👤 Member for 16 years 10 months

that is incorrect making a wbs inactivie DOES NOT DISSOLVE THE WBS it is still there 

A
Alexandre Faulx-Briole 👤 Member for 23 years 4 months

Zoltan,

To make a wbs node inactive does the same as make taks inactive in MS Project: or disolve tasks in P6:

P6 schedules the tasks as if the inactive node did not exist; the previous and the next node are linked together as if the inactive one has never existed

Deleting a node is one for all, Making a node inactive is an on/off process

Alexandre

Z
Zoltan Palffy 👤 Member for 16 years 10 months

I never use it I guess if a wbs elemet is no longer necessary or is placed on hold you can make it inactive.

The only place where I see this being used is if you have a standard template setup for your projects. 

Let's say that you have submittals & reviews listed by ALL of the master specification number i.e. electrical is 26. 

so you have all of the specification sections listed as a standard in the wbs then for this particular project you do not have specification number 27 communications in your scope for this particular proejct then you can make this particualr wbs INACTIVE instead of deleting it.

I personally would delete it.  

A
Alexandre Faulx-Briole 👤 Member for 23 years 4 months

Hi Zolta,

so, what is the reason of the Status field in the WBS Detail form, General?

is it a mistake of the Primavera Dev Dept?

Alexandre

Forum Sponsor

Top Posters

Julian Pegg
1 posts
Peter Nagy
2 posts
Raymund de Laza
17 posts
Syed_Asad
0 posts
Tony Greyvenstein
0 posts
Ahmed Al-Jubouri
13 posts
Umar Alvi
3 posts
Sibusiso Mahlalela
0 posts
Michael Samanyayi
3 posts
Simon Gumede
0 posts