Different Durations of WBS and the Project

Hi. How can a duration of a WBS can be 50 days however upper level WBS and the project lasts 36 days at the same time?

Oracle Primavera - PM6

Rafael Davila 👤 Member for 22 years 3 months

Sun, 2019-12-08 18:25 · Permalink

I would call it WEIRD math to define duration using dates at one WBS level and sum of values within another WBS level.

What is the logic of this?
Why not inverting the calculation rules?
When you can have multiple calendars and the software calculations are in hours rolling-up days can yield wrong values.
Because the calculations for days are based on averages calculation of duration in days can be misleading. Although never as good as showing durations in hours if you have the urge to show days better show remaining workdays considering every workday duration in hours can be different.
a single activity with a calendar where different days have different work hours.
as you add resource calendars duration in days can get very weird, even if for a single activity.
Adding more activities as well as WBS phases makes it worse at the WBS levels.
For simple calendars and resource loading it make sense to use days as an option to enter activity duration.

Zoltan Palffy 👤 Member for 16 years 10 months

Fri, 2019-12-06 18:20 · Permalink

At the Construction WBS the 36 days are working days from 12/31/2019 to 2/18/2020

At the Structural WBS the 50 days are the total of all of the workings days under that wbs

6+3+8+6+4+5+5+8+5=50

its straight math

Sterling Gallagher 👤 Member for 6 years 8 months

Thu, 2019-12-05 14:18 · Permalink

Santosh is spot on with his comment. If you change your user preference settings to hours they should match.

Rafael Davila 👤 Member for 22 years 3 months

Wed, 2019-12-04 12:00 · Permalink

What happens if you show all durations in hours?

Santosh Bhat 👤 Member for 21 years 1 month

Tue, 2019-12-03 23:15 · Permalink

It has to do with calendars. Where activities within a WBS group contain a mixture of calendars, the Proejct Default Calendar is used to calculate duration at the WBS Group level.

If you display your calendar column you'll see why.

Menu

Different Durations of WBS and the Project

Top Posters

Menu

Different Durations of WBS and the Project

Forum Sponsor

Spider Project is most functional and powerful professional project management software.

Top Posters