Logic MS Project
Forum Sponsor
Top Posters
Peter Holroyd
51 posts
fridau
0 posts
Rahmat Hidayat
32 posts
pinoyplanner
1 posts
James Williams
74 posts
Saqib Ullah
1 posts
Luyanda Ndlumbini
2 posts
Jeff Waldrop
6 posts
Robert Roy
1 posts
Tony Wright
4 posts
Hi Bo,
you are right, in your example it will work.
It will not work with the start milestone preceeding A, but will work with start milesone succeding A start.
I understood your proposal as the link to Finish milestone of activity B. In this case this milestone may be delayed without delaying B.
Thank you and Best Regards,
Vladimir
Hi Vladimir,
Im not sure I understand you correctly.
Take your example: Let A in my example be "Preparation of Trench" and B be "Laying down Pipes". The finish-milestone C is then "Completion of Preparation of Trench".
"Laying down Pipes" (B) can start SS+x days after "Preparation of Trench" (A) has started, but "Laying down Pipes" (B) cant complete before FF+y days after the finish-milestone "Completion of Preparation of Trench" (C). If finish of A gets delayed, the milestone C will get delayed and thereby also the finish of B.
I think we mean the same, however, please clarify about the resources being limited if Ive misunderstood something.
Best regards,
Bo
Hi Bo,
it will not work correctly when resources are limited.
Activity may be finished but finish milestone delayed if preceding activity finished later.
Such links are typical for linear projects.
You can start laying down pipes when the certain length of the trench is ready, you can not finish laying pipes until the whole trench is ready.
Best Regards,
Vladimir
Plan Plan,
If you really want to use SS and FF between the same two tasks, you can do it in MS Project, but it will "cost" you an additional milestone everytime you want to do it.
Say task A and B. Introduce finish-milestone C being FSed (0 lag) to A. Let B be SS+x lag to A and also FF+y lag to C.
You can also so it the other way around, i.e. with a start-milestone and then just swap the links.
Regards,
Bo
Vladimir, wow, I am so surprised that you do not agree. I will change my opinion accordingly straight away.
Hi Trevor,
I dont agree that both SS and FF links between two tasks is never needed. In most cases you shall use them both.
Best Regards,
Vladimir
Not sure why you ask. They can. They cant both be used between the same tasks at the same time, but such a thing is never needed.