Labour Effectiveness
Forum Sponsor
Top Posters
Julian Pegg
1 posts
Peter Nagy
2 posts
Raymund de Laza
17 posts
Syed_Asad
0 posts
Tony Greyvenstein
0 posts
Ahmed Al-Jubouri
13 posts
Umar Alvi
3 posts
Sibusiso Mahlalela
0 posts
Michael Samanyayi
3 posts
Simon Gumede
0 posts
hi can somebody drop a copy at [email protected]?
Mr. Armand
Can i have the copy too. Please send it to my email [email protected]
Thanks.
AMP
Armando,
I get your point. Yes, experience and sound judgement of the planner will also help. For the certain weights, you can check with distributions that are widely applied in business (e.g. normal, beta ...) and for pareto distribution, I will check that out.
Regards,
Ed
Edd,
Appreciate your comments, Ill take it into consideration and give feed back soon.
With regards to the factor, for the moment I just cant think of other figure or formula how to derive it. But, nevertheless this is how I got it. When my wife went into series of surgical operations late last year, all the doctors checking her up, would always start by asking her, in the scale of 1 to 10 what is the level of pain??? So I just tried to apply that 1 to 10 logic to the unknown Labour Effectiveness Factor that I have. Meaning, it would therefore be depending on the planner to measure based on judgement what is that factor in the scale of 1 to 10 (10 refers to the total of all the factors that you being the planner would choose and decide to apply).
Another thing is that, do you think the Pareto principle would apply to this?
Praju,
Just sent to you the file...Expecting your feedback soon...
Regards,
Arman
Can i have the file too ..may be i can contribute something...pls send the same to [email protected]
Hi Armando,
I have take a quick look on what you are trying to do. These are my observations:
1. First, you have an ideal productivity rate, then based on certain factors you add additional weights to come up with an effective productivity rate which usually higher than the ideal. In reality, I believe that true, there are some factors that can cause an effect regarding labours productivity, however it must be pointed out that certain factors is not linear in nature. You just cant come up with a 1% for this and 2% for that.
2. I admire your list of factors, it is quite extensive. My opinion though, can it be summarize into lets say 5 types? Social, Political, Economical, Geographical and Physical components. And through each type, you have these baskets of factors. Each five will have its distinct weights that will then add to the ideal productivity.
More power and lets keep planning forward.
Regards,
Ed
HI Ed,
Just sent to you the file.
My intention actually is to establish certain ideal conditions and its up for us to quantify the degree of difficulty for each specific situation which affect labour effectiveness.
Please give your feed back once you studied the file.
Thanks,
Arman
Hi Armando,
Can u send me a copy? ([email protected]). Just wondering, is that only for a specific industry? like Oil & Gas?
Thanks,
Ed
Ryan,
Just sent to you the file..
Sanjeev has a good project and I tried to model out something on pipe welding. I indicated the factors I believe is ok. Please let me know also your judgements on the factors by filling it up on the column I provided for you and send the updated file back to me...
Please let me know also should you have further comments...
Regards,
Arman
Mr.Arman ,
Can you please send me also a copy at [email protected] a lot.
Mr.Arman ,
Can you please send me also a copy at [email protected] a lot.
Mr. Catalan,
Just sent to you the file.Hope to receive your comments and suggestions soon...
Nicholas,
Your right, appreciate your comments...I did a terrible mistake of my formula ...Thanks a lot...
Arman
Hi Arman,
Could you please send me the file as well at [email protected].
Cheers,
Thanks Nicolas...
I thought you did not receive the file.
Its ok and Ill do the update first of the file and keep you posted...
With regards to that "Very Strict Safety Factor...", I just had that experience before of basically the same piece of work but the implementing safety standards were too different. It took a lot pressure inspite of the experience and technical know how to execute the job...
Regards,
Arman
Hi Arman,
Tks for the file which is very thorough and
necessitated a lot of input.
- However, I fail to grasp a few items,
you mention three columns low, medium and high,
yet you fill in only one?
- since you multiply the manhours per factors,
if all factors should be nill
(like resource loading or major equipment)
then the manhours would be also ?!
- For ethical reasons, I would rename your
"Very strict Safety Health and Environmental Regulations"
in
"Potentially dangerous products or environment"
I do not think safety regulation hinders productivity in fine.
keep up the good work.
Ruel,
Just sent to you the file...
Thanks,
Arman
forgot [email protected]
Hi Armand,
could you send me the file as well.
TIA
Daniel,
I just emailed to you my file which I started. I would be expecting your comments on it...
Regards,
Arman
Hi Arman,
Your question regarding "type of contract" Yes in some ways, especially in the Philippines in small type of construction works. Daily Wage Vs Lump Sum contract may affect labour effectiveness.
The highest factor would be the "Level of Skill" followed by using the right "equipment and tools". I think they go hand in hand.
Another factor is "team work", When I attended a seminar in "grid management" I found out that even if you put together a highly skilled and talented people in a team, if they do not work as a team, productivity will be low. Especially people with strong personalities put together in one team does not work, as there will be clashes of ideas and will. Team building is necessary in this case.
Cheers,
Daniel
Hi Arman,
My email address: [email protected]
Kindly send the latest.
Regards,
Daniel
Sinan,
Just sent to you the file...
Hope to hear your comments and suggestions soon...
Thanks,
Arman
Nicolas,
Just sent to you the file...
You may add your items and please send the updated file to me and expecting your comments as well on the format then percentages, etc...
The last two items on your list did caught my attention and in my personal rating, it should have a greater factors among the five items on your lists. I would be glad also if you could demonstrate your judgement(percentage) or the ratings I put on the file by putting yours on the column next to mine...
Thanks,
Arman
Hi all,
This thread is very promising,
I should add:
- distance to prefab shops
- square meter available per worker
- type of storage for equipment to erect
- workers unionized or not
- retribution system of workers (per item or per day)
I Would very much like to see the work in progress
please send a copy to
[email protected]
dear my friend,
could you forward the file to my email in order to share with my recorded productivity.
my email is
[email protected]
Daniel,
I still dont have any final version as I am still asking for comments, suggestions from anybody who would want to contribute something...
can you give me your email address so that I could send you a copy of the sample of what I started?
Thanks too mate,
Arman
Arman,
Can you please publish here the final version of this subject.
Thanks mate,
Daniel
Ashraf,
Just sent to you the file...Is religion has any contribution to labor effectiveness in your region?
Looking forward to hear your comments soon...
Regards,
Arman
Dear can i have a copy at ashraf_abdlmonem@ yahoo.com
Regards
Shaiju,
Just sent to you the file...Hope to hear your comments, suggestions and queries soon...
Regards,
Arman
Armando,
This is a good innovation. You can send me the file to [email protected].
Regards
Shaiju,
I am very glad that you are interested to contribute and share your ideas, experience and expertise...
Yes, you are right, these productivities are unique in all projects in terms of type, geography, etc. I have seen a couple of productivity manuals generated outside here in the Philippines then looking at particularly the same basic activities, the productivities are far different. Part of what I am thinking and asking is why is the huge difference??? How am I going to quantify these factors that affects productivities in both local and global terms??? That is where Im started to think of having a checklist that might give me some answers, probably calculations then derive some figures with the help of planners within the PP community...
How could I send you the file of what I started so that you could start with your comments, ideas?
Regards,
Arman
Hi Armando & Daniel,
What you are trying to figure out is interesting. I can also contribute something into it.
I think your intention is to calculate how the environmental factors are affecting the productivity. As we all know productivity is inversely propotional to time taken. So the less productivity means more time taken to do the job. This more time is actually the "Lost time". So there is a "Lost time" associated with all the factors that you mentioned here. It will be unique in all projects.
So my suggetion is to weight the factors based on the Lost time assocoated with it.
Daniel,
Appreciate your reply...Thanks...
Actually, my intention is to generate a comprehensive list of all factors that affects labour effectivess. I will use these factors in my programming works such as duration derivation, resource loadings, etc.
I will include to your 7 items on my list and probably simplify further. I also have CONSTRUCTION EQPT. & TOOLS, ACCESS TO WORK, CONSTRUCTION PROGRAM, MATERIAL & ENGINEERING COORDINATION. Do you think a TYPE OF CONTRACT also has a factor?
I have a follow up question, in your 7 items, which do you is the highest factor and maybe lowest as well.
I will give you a copy my spreadsheet should you be interested and maybe you could also have comments i.e. format and factors...
Thanks,
Arman
Factors that may affect labour effectiveness:
1.) Supervision
2.) Too much overtime may lead to burnout and work efficiency usually declines after a couple of weeks.
3.) Communication - Clear and well define objectives.
4.) Quality of Labour (level of skill may vary from one country to another)
5.) Weather conditions
6.) General Welfare of workers.
7.) Religion and Culture may be a factor