Critical Slack Calculation

N
Niek Zonneveld 👤 Member for 21 years 3 months

Yes you are right Vladimir, resource dependencies are just as important as precedence logic, and if you touch the levelling button in MSP, you can be sure that the task flag "critical" means next to nothing.



Assuming John knows this, he could use a formula to drive one of the custom flag fields and then use that flag to mark a Gantt bar as critical based on hourly thresholds rather than the standard days.



I’m out of my territory here but I think in a one-day plant shutdown resource constraints are of lesser concern.

V
Vladimir Liberzon 👤 Member for 25 years 4 months

John,

if you created resource-constrained schedule then total slacks showed by MS Project are wrong. So it does not make sense to pay attention to these data at all (days or hours - they are wrong in any case).

N
Niek Zonneveld 👤 Member for 21 years 3 months

I think what John is referring to is the setting under [tools] [options] [calculation]: Task are critical if slack...



I also think the answer is "No"



HTH

A
Alexandre Faulx-Briole 👤 Member for 23 years 5 months

John,

MSP uses the same unit for the critical slack duration and the task duration; key in task duration in hours to get slack in hours on the gantt chart

Alexandre

Forum Sponsor

Top Posters

Luis Jr Ngade
6 posts
Ben Welsher
1 posts
Rohan Dashputre
0 posts
AMECHI ANAKWENZE
2 posts
Jayaprakash Sekar
1 posts
arash.karmand
0 posts
James Williams
74 posts
Vahidazimi01
0 posts
David Smith
4 posts
Peter Holroyd
51 posts