Primavera Risk Analysis - Getting the absolute minimum and maximum

A
Alireza R 👤 Member for 6 years 4 months

Hi all,

 

I have a very detailed risk analysis for my project (different risks, different uncertainties with different distributions,...). And now I would like to see the "absolute" minimum and maximum end dates.

Ofcourse since Monte Carlo Analysis is based on random iterations, I can never say with certainty what the shortest project duration is (think extremely happy flow, all uncertainties getting the minimum durations). I get the minimum from OPRA but next time I run the simulation I might get a new minimum (or maximum).

I know this defies the purpose of statistical nature of Monte Carlo but I am wondering whether there is an option to first find the extreme values on the both ends of the spectrum and then fill in the between (something like a polygraph, jumping to the both extremes first and then filling the values the fall within those two).

 

I have tried increasing the iterations to 20000 (higher than 99% confidence level) but this still is not hitting the sweet spots.

 

any ideas?

 

br.

AR

V
Vladimir Liberzon 👤 Member for 25 years 4 months

David,

Spider Project creates optimistic and pessimistic project versions.

Optimistic uses optimistic estimates of project parameters and includes risk events with more than 90% probabilities to occur, pessimistic uses pessimistic estimates of project parameters and includes all risk events.

D
David Kelly 👤 Member for 21 years 8 months

As you admit yourself, your question kind of undermines the whole ethos of probabilistic analysis. There are no “deterministically” best and worst dates following a probabilistic analysis.

You could choose to calculate and save the 1% and 99% percentiles, and ensure you are using Monte Carlo and not Latin Hypercube sampling, both of which you will find in the Risk Analysis Options.

Forum Sponsor

Top Posters

AMECHI ANAKWENZE
2 posts
Jayaprakash Sekar
1 posts
arash.karmand
0 posts
James Williams
74 posts
Vahidazimi01
0 posts
David Smith
4 posts
Peter Holroyd
51 posts
fridau
0 posts
Rahmat Hidayat
32 posts
pinoyplanner
1 posts