Best Planning Software

K
kath heenan 👤 Member for 11 years 4 months

Hi there

Ive recently moved to a new company and went from using P6 to MS Project, i havent had any training on MS Project and basically taught myself over the last 5 weeks. Trouble is its not a great resource utilisation tool - i may be wrong on this so please dont shoot me down for saying that! 

Anyway my post is really to ask which tool is the best software to use for a small oil company with a manufacturing workshop to enable forecasting and resource utilisation along with 'whatif' analysis. P6 is quite expensive and im not sure i would be able to convince them of the costs involved.

Thanks in advance

S
Stephen Devaux 👤 Member for 21 years 2 months

My only comment is that it is hard for me to imagine using a project management software package that does not provide the most critical metric of critical path analysis: drag. Neither Primavera nor Asta Spider, nor most other packages, computes critical path drag. Spider project computes drag on both CPM and resource schedules.

Fraternally in project management,

Steve the Bajan

M
Murray Geddes 👤 Member for 22 years 3 months

To be fair, the term "Best" is subjective.

Most software packages available are able to cost load & resource, but some are more functional than others.

Having used a large number of the commercially available planning packages aimed at the construction sector, I found that both CS Project & Asta PowerProject were both functional and cost effective, with a relatively short learning curve if you are able to use another planning package at a reasonably profficient level.

M
MOHAMED RAJAKANI 👤 Member for 11 years 5 months
I have been assigned to prepare a masterplan Progress Tracking Tools Piping for EPC Chlorine project , starting from Large Boring Piping Prefabrication ,Large Boring Pipe Supports Prefabrication ,Large Boring Pipe Supports Erection ,Small Boring Pipe Erection ,Punch Listing ,Flushing Testing and PreCommissioning ,Lines Instatement,procurement,constructioin/installation , testing and commisioning of pipeline.
I am in need of a sample Progress Tracking for Piping Templates for EPC project....
Thank you in Advance
R
Rafael Davila 👤 Member for 22 years 3 months
Deleted by Rafael Davila as to avoid annoying requests to revive this discussion as it is older tha 3 years.

Forum Sponsor

Top Posters

Julian Pegg
1 posts
Peter Nagy
2 posts
Raymund de Laza
17 posts
Syed_Asad
0 posts
Tony Greyvenstein
0 posts
Ahmed Al-Jubouri
13 posts
Umar Alvi
3 posts
Sibusiso Mahlalela
0 posts
Michael Samanyayi
3 posts
Simon Gumede
0 posts