I don’t think there is a way to stop MS Project grouping alphanumerically. Many, if not all, Microsoft applications sort from A-Z or Z-A, try creating folders in Windows Explorer and Outlook and you’ll get the same result.
It is exactly for this reason you need ‘persuade’ MS Project to group as you require, by including an alphanumeric prefix for January / February / March / etc.
I tested your problem using four rows (1 / 2 / 3 / 4) and four values (a Jan / b Feb / c Mar / d Apr). I didn’t use a description. I also ticked the same check boxes you described in Post #1. This method grouped as follows:
a Jan
b Feb
c Mar
d Apr
Without the prefixes MS Project grouped alphabetically.
All I can suggest is if you are already using a prefix and when you group it still doesn’t display the values in the order you require, try recreating the Value list criteria in a spare text field.
Again if it doesn’t group correctly, try creating a new file to use as a test file and inserting four tasks. Use the same Value List criteria and see if you have the same problem. If you don’t, it may be a problem with the original file. If you do, it may be a problem with MS Project itself.
Regards,
Darren
Member for
18 years 2 months
Member for18 years2 months
Submitted by ronaldo celestino on Thu, 2008-07-31 07:05
Thanks anyway, but i think this is one of the bugs of MSP2003.. by the way i also tried MSP 2007 before but i shifted back to MSP2003 coz of so many bugs in 2007 especially in grouping & outline codes...
more power in planning...
Member for
22 years 9 months
Member for22 years9 months
Submitted by Alexandre Faul… on Mon, 2008-07-28 08:11
Thanks for your reply, im using MSP2003. Still, it doesnt work on me. It shows me the grouping alphabetically & not the way ive arranged them by row.
It groups like this;
April
February
March
January
I wanted to group them as below;
January
February
March
April
I may be skipping some steps. I tried to fix it but unfortunately failed to do so. Can u give me some advice.
regards
Member for
22 years 9 months
Member for22 years9 months
Submitted by Alexandre Faul… on Sun, 2008-07-27 09:55
Member for
17 years 9 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Ronaldo,
I think that ‘By row number’ only applies to how they are displayed in the drop-down list, not when then are grouped.
You can define group intervals in the ‘Customize Group By’ dialog box, but even that functionality is extremely limited.
I don’t see any other way apart from prefixing I’m afraid.
Regards,
Darren
Member for
18 years 2 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Darren,
This only proves that choosing "By row number" under "Display order..." does not work for the purpose.
Thanks anyway, ive been using this for quite some time, I thought theres a way to resolve this without using prefix.
Thanks,
Ronaldo
Member for
17 years 9 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Ronaldo,
I don’t think there is a way to stop MS Project grouping alphanumerically. Many, if not all, Microsoft applications sort from A-Z or Z-A, try creating folders in Windows Explorer and Outlook and you’ll get the same result.
It is exactly for this reason you need ‘persuade’ MS Project to group as you require, by including an alphanumeric prefix for January / February / March / etc.
I tested your problem using four rows (1 / 2 / 3 / 4) and four values (a Jan / b Feb / c Mar / d Apr). I didn’t use a description. I also ticked the same check boxes you described in Post #1. This method grouped as follows:
a Jan
b Feb
c Mar
d Apr
Without the prefixes MS Project grouped alphabetically.
All I can suggest is if you are already using a prefix and when you group it still doesn’t display the values in the order you require, try recreating the Value list criteria in a spare text field.
Again if it doesn’t group correctly, try creating a new file to use as a test file and inserting four tasks. Use the same Value List criteria and see if you have the same problem. If you don’t, it may be a problem with the original file. If you do, it may be a problem with MS Project itself.
Regards,
Darren
Member for
18 years 2 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Hi Darren,
If u input those data, it is alphabetically arrrnaged, try to input them as follows;
January
February
March
April
please try to remove Months 1/2/3/4 from the field Value...
Regards
Member for
17 years 9 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Hi Ronaldo,
I use MS Project 2k3 SP2 and Alexandre’s suggestion worked fine for me. I also tried these values:
Month 1: Jan
Month 2: Feb
Month 3: Mar
Month 4: Apr
They worked as well.
Have you tried this out on any other project files and are getting the same results, or is it just the one project you’re having this problem with?
Regards,
Darren
Member for
18 years 2 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Alexandre,
Same here...
Ronaldo
Member for
22 years 9 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Ronaldo,
I am working on MSP 2003 Pro SP1
Alexandre
Member for
18 years 2 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Thanks anyway, but i think this is one of the bugs of MSP2003.. by the way i also tried MSP 2007 before but i shifted back to MSP2003 coz of so many bugs in 2007 especially in grouping & outline codes...
more power in planning...
Member for
22 years 9 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Oh, damned!
my precedent post should read
Value: 1, 2, 3, 4
Description: "a January", "b February", aso
Alexandre
Member for
18 years 2 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Alexandre,
From the "Value list for..." (Customize Fields of Text1),
I created the ff.:
Row: 1,2,3,4
Value:a,b,c,d
Description:January, February, March,April
...respectively
no check "For use a value from..."
...i checked "Allow addtl..." & "Append.." and
checked "By row number" under "Display order for dropdown list"
Still , I didnt get the order that i wanted.
regards
Member for
22 years 9 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Ronaldo,
I did this way
Custom field = Text1 (Task)
List of values, no default value, user cannot enter his own values
Code Description
1 a January
2 b February
3 c March
4 d April
I added Text1 to some task table, then:
When I select one value in the drop down list, I can only see the codes
When I build a group on Text1, my taks are correctly sorted, starting with January, ending with April (in my test)
All the best
Alexandre
Member for
18 years 2 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Alexandre,
Thanks for your reply, im using MSP2003. Still, it doesnt work on me. It shows me the grouping alphabetically & not the way ive arranged them by row.
It groups like this;
April
February
March
January
I wanted to group them as below;
January
February
March
April
I may be skipping some steps. I tried to fix it but unfortunately failed to do so. Can u give me some advice.
regards
Member for
22 years 9 monthsRE: Customized Fields
Ronaldo,
it works well with MS Project 2003; are you using MS Project 2007 by the way? it is plenty of bugs, you should upgrade to SP1
Alexandre
Member for
18 years 2 monthsRE: Customized Fields
In addition to my post... I want it to view in grouping like this;
January
Task 1
Task 2
February
Task 3
Task 4
March
Task 5
Task 6
April
Task 7
Task 8
but instead it shows me arranged alphabeltically...
April
Task 7
Task 8
February
Task 3
Task 4
March
Task 5
Task 6
January
Task 1
Task 2
I need your expert advice please...
regards