I was in a discussion today with an expert in this field and he stated that a person should take a "professional" degree after about 7 years of practice.
This will make a difference only when they have to select amongst equal candidates.
I have read your thread with interest. I earn my very good living as a forensic delay analyst and the most useful qualification I earned was GCE carpentry - 50 odd years ago.
If anyone asks I tell them I am an "unqualified success".
Apply for the Planning Engineers Organisation - when your thesis is accepted you will have the letters MPEO to your name - this is recognised more and more around the world.
I should add that the second most useful qualification I have is MPEO.
Best regards
Mike Testro
Member for
19 years 7 months
Member for19 years7 months
Submitted by rosie finnegan on Tue, 2008-09-16 13:22
I fully suport Carmens idea. PMP, Prince2 or others would be a helpful certificate.
Now you have some years of experience. Did you ever see an electrician plan a piping, a mechanical engineer plan instrumentation? As a planner you must have a broad area of technical understanding and feeling, must have excellent communication and presentation skills, be able to structurize tasks, be able to read a tender or a contract, have some understanding on cost controls. Most are NOT basics of engineering.
Dont be afraid. Dont be discouraged by ignorants! Have some self confidence, because YOU have experience.
Please dont misunderstand me. For planning and scheduling more skills are required in addition to engineering. Engineers must learn different things.
Regards
Dieter
Member for
21 years 4 months
Member for21 years4 months
Submitted by Carmen Arape on Tue, 2008-09-16 11:39
people come to different jobs through different channels and I think at the end of the day if one is unable to function in a particular role then the employer will soon see this and hopefully act accordingly.
As far as Im aware there is no accredited Planning Degree course and therefore it is a profession that people gravitate to because they love it. thats the case for me anyway.
Im very confident of my abilities as a planner I cant however speak up for Process designers.
thanks again for you response
I do find this forum very informative and helpful.
rosie
Member for
21 years 4 months
Member for21 years4 months
Submitted by Carmen Arape on Tue, 2008-09-16 10:46
I hope that my words do not offend you. That was not the intention.
I have a technical degree, years of experience based on Home office and site. And I would like to have a certificate coming from any respectable institution.
I was wondering WHY I do not find process designers without technical degree and just years of experience.
Cheers,
Member for
19 years 7 months
Member for19 years7 months
Submitted by rosie finnegan on Tue, 2008-09-16 10:27
I can classify 4 key players in the business of projects:
Client
EPC contractor (including CM construction management)
Design contractor (ONLY)
Construction Contractor (ONLY)
Within these 3 key players, you can consider:
Size and business
For instance, regarding size you can find:
Small, medium or big projects.
Regarding business, you can find :
Oil& Gas, chemical , mining, power and so ON.
Any Key player, executing big or medium projects in the Oil& Gas Business is requesting a technical degree. Just experience is no longer valid. According to my experience and in America (South).
Wait for others planners to post comments regarding Europe or UK.
Cheers,
Member for
18 years 9 months
Member for18 years9 months
Submitted by Dieter Wambach on Tue, 2008-09-16 10:11
This will depend on the company. There are many companies where any activity for hiring is restricted to engineers - others are not able to structure a project and to create a plan, they believe. It depends on the power of the user department against HR as well - strong HR no or little chance, strong involvement of planning team, big chances for you. For contractual work it should be easier for you.
Member for
19 years 10 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Hi
All are created equal but some end up more equal than others
Best regards
Mike Testro
Member for
21 years 4 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Anoon,
your thought is wrong
Member for
19 years 1 monthRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
"This will make a difference only when they have to select amongst equal candidates".
i thought all men are created equal?
Member for
17 years 3 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Dear Rosie,
I was in a discussion today with an expert in this field and he stated that a person should take a "professional" degree after about 7 years of practice.
This will make a difference only when they have to select amongst equal candidates.
Good luck,
Samer
Member for
19 years 10 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Hi Rosie
I have read your thread with interest. I earn my very good living as a forensic delay analyst and the most useful qualification I earned was GCE carpentry - 50 odd years ago.
If anyone asks I tell them I am an "unqualified success".
Apply for the Planning Engineers Organisation - when your thesis is accepted you will have the letters MPEO to your name - this is recognised more and more around the world.
I should add that the second most useful qualification I have is MPEO.
Best regards
Mike Testro
Member for
19 years 7 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
guys,
again thanks for the info.
I have of course had constant training while on the job i.e.
P3E (V5) advanced planning
Project Mangement ITMA diploma
Risk assesment managment
to name but a few
but my initial post was about a particular technical degree.
I will certainly check out the sites you sent me.
rosie
Member for
18 years 9 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Rosie
I fully suport Carmens idea. PMP, Prince2 or others would be a helpful certificate.
Now you have some years of experience. Did you ever see an electrician plan a piping, a mechanical engineer plan instrumentation? As a planner you must have a broad area of technical understanding and feeling, must have excellent communication and presentation skills, be able to structurize tasks, be able to read a tender or a contract, have some understanding on cost controls. Most are NOT basics of engineering.
Dont be afraid. Dont be discouraged by ignorants! Have some self confidence, because YOU have experience.
Please dont misunderstand me. For planning and scheduling more skills are required in addition to engineering. Engineers must learn different things.
Regards
Dieter
Member for
21 years 4 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
R F ,
You do not have to gravitate, please check following association:
Planning Engineers Organization (UK)
American Institute of certified planners
PMI - project management institute
Search in this forum under “Project services career issues” some threads about the theme HOW to get a certificate.
Cheers,
Member for
19 years 7 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Carmen,
your words do not offend at all.
people come to different jobs through different channels and I think at the end of the day if one is unable to function in a particular role then the employer will soon see this and hopefully act accordingly.
As far as Im aware there is no accredited Planning Degree course and therefore it is a profession that people gravitate to because they love it. thats the case for me anyway.
Im very confident of my abilities as a planner I cant however speak up for Process designers.
thanks again for you response
I do find this forum very informative and helpful.
rosie
Member for
21 years 4 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
R F,
I hope that my words do not offend you. That was not the intention.
I have a technical degree, years of experience based on Home office and site. And I would like to have a certificate coming from any respectable institution.
I was wondering WHY I do not find process designers without technical degree and just years of experience.
Cheers,
Member for
19 years 7 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Thanks for the response guys,
I not too convinced that Im doing a worse job than any other planner simply because i have no degree.
I have proven again and again that Im up to the challenge.
Ill just have to prove that in any upcomming interviews.
thanks again
r.f.
Member for
21 years 4 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Rosie,
It depends of the Company you are looking for.
I can classify 4 key players in the business of projects:
Client
EPC contractor (including CM construction management)
Design contractor (ONLY)
Construction Contractor (ONLY)
Within these 3 key players, you can consider:
Size and business
For instance, regarding size you can find:
Small, medium or big projects.
Regarding business, you can find :
Oil& Gas, chemical , mining, power and so ON.
Any Key player, executing big or medium projects in the Oil& Gas Business is requesting a technical degree. Just experience is no longer valid. According to my experience and in America (South).
Wait for others planners to post comments regarding Europe or UK.
Cheers,
Member for
18 years 9 monthsRE: Planning Engineer without a Degree
Hi Rosie
This will depend on the company. There are many companies where any activity for hiring is restricted to engineers - others are not able to structure a project and to create a plan, they believe. It depends on the power of the user department against HR as well - strong HR no or little chance, strong involvement of planning team, big chances for you. For contractual work it should be easier for you.
Its just my private opinion.
Good luck!
Dieter