Primavera Project Planner - P3 Member for 20 years 2 months Member for 20 years 2 months Submitted by MUHAMMAD IQBAL on Wed, 2006-09-20 02:47 Permalink RE: EVMS and P3 HELLO ABAS THIS SIMPLE EVM FORMULA WILL NOT HELP YOU IN FORECASTING THE COMPLETION DATE OF ANY TASK OR WHOLE PROJECT. P3 FINISH DATE WILL BE ONLY REALISTIC WHEN MOST OF THE LOGIC ARE F-S AND THE PHYSICAL WORK IS GOING AS PER PLAN I MEAN NO OUT OF SCUENCE WORK SO THERE IS ONLY WAY OUT IS PERFORMANCE BASE ANALYSIS THIS IS SIMILAER TO EVMA BUT ONE STEP MORE WE ARE VERY SUCCESSFULLY USUING IT IN OUR PROJECTS AND I HAVE ALSO USED IT IN DUBAI POWER PROJECT IT WORKS WELL FOR FURTHER INFO braintask@yahoo.com IQBAL Member for 19 years 3 months Member for 19 years 4 months Submitted by Abbas Shakourifar on Mon, 2006-07-17 10:41 Permalink RE: EVMS and P3 SPI= (BCWP)/(BCWS) or for each activity (Plan Value) / (Earned Value) or Plan/Actual in Earned Value Management System : ETC= ATE/ %C or ETC= ATE + (OD-ATE*SPI)/SPI or ETC= OD/SPI But in P3 Calculations: ETC = ATE + (1-%C)*OD SPI: Schedule Performance Index BCWP: Budgeted Cost of Work Performed BCWS: Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled ATE: Actual Time Expended %C: % Complete OD: Original Duration Member for 19 years 5 months Member for 19 years 6 months Submitted by Praves Suppa on Mon, 2006-07-17 07:56 Permalink RE: EVMS and P3 Hello, If we are agreed for the relation of 3 variables is BCWP = SPI x (BQ - ETC) in my assumption that BCWS = BQ ACWP = BCWS - ETC So you have all these 3 variable in P3 Calculation. Sorry if this comment cannot fulfill your query. BR. Praves Log in or register to post comments
Member for 20 years 2 months Member for 20 years 2 months Submitted by MUHAMMAD IQBAL on Wed, 2006-09-20 02:47 Permalink RE: EVMS and P3 HELLO ABAS THIS SIMPLE EVM FORMULA WILL NOT HELP YOU IN FORECASTING THE COMPLETION DATE OF ANY TASK OR WHOLE PROJECT. P3 FINISH DATE WILL BE ONLY REALISTIC WHEN MOST OF THE LOGIC ARE F-S AND THE PHYSICAL WORK IS GOING AS PER PLAN I MEAN NO OUT OF SCUENCE WORK SO THERE IS ONLY WAY OUT IS PERFORMANCE BASE ANALYSIS THIS IS SIMILAER TO EVMA BUT ONE STEP MORE WE ARE VERY SUCCESSFULLY USUING IT IN OUR PROJECTS AND I HAVE ALSO USED IT IN DUBAI POWER PROJECT IT WORKS WELL FOR FURTHER INFO braintask@yahoo.com IQBAL
Member for 19 years 3 months Member for 19 years 4 months Submitted by Abbas Shakourifar on Mon, 2006-07-17 10:41 Permalink RE: EVMS and P3 SPI= (BCWP)/(BCWS) or for each activity (Plan Value) / (Earned Value) or Plan/Actual in Earned Value Management System : ETC= ATE/ %C or ETC= ATE + (OD-ATE*SPI)/SPI or ETC= OD/SPI But in P3 Calculations: ETC = ATE + (1-%C)*OD SPI: Schedule Performance Index BCWP: Budgeted Cost of Work Performed BCWS: Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled ATE: Actual Time Expended %C: % Complete OD: Original Duration
Member for 19 years 5 months Member for 19 years 6 months Submitted by Praves Suppa on Mon, 2006-07-17 07:56 Permalink RE: EVMS and P3 Hello, If we are agreed for the relation of 3 variables is BCWP = SPI x (BQ - ETC) in my assumption that BCWS = BQ ACWP = BCWS - ETC So you have all these 3 variable in P3 Calculation. Sorry if this comment cannot fulfill your query. BR. Praves
Member for
20 years 2 monthsRE: EVMS and P3
HELLO ABAS
THIS SIMPLE EVM FORMULA WILL NOT HELP YOU IN FORECASTING THE COMPLETION DATE OF ANY TASK OR WHOLE PROJECT.
P3 FINISH DATE WILL BE ONLY REALISTIC WHEN MOST OF THE LOGIC ARE F-S AND THE PHYSICAL WORK IS GOING AS PER PLAN I MEAN NO OUT OF SCUENCE WORK
SO THERE IS ONLY WAY OUT IS PERFORMANCE BASE ANALYSIS
THIS IS SIMILAER TO EVMA BUT ONE STEP MORE
WE ARE VERY SUCCESSFULLY USUING IT IN OUR PROJECTS
AND I HAVE ALSO USED IT IN DUBAI POWER PROJECT IT WORKS WELL
FOR FURTHER INFO
braintask@yahoo.com
IQBAL
Member for
19 years 3 monthsRE: EVMS and P3
SPI= (BCWP)/(BCWS) or for each activity (Plan Value) / (Earned Value) or Plan/Actual
in Earned Value Management System :
ETC= ATE/ %C or
ETC= ATE + (OD-ATE*SPI)/SPI or
ETC= OD/SPI
But in P3 Calculations:
ETC = ATE + (1-%C)*OD
SPI: Schedule Performance Index
BCWP: Budgeted Cost of Work Performed
BCWS: Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled
ATE: Actual Time Expended
%C: % Complete
OD: Original Duration
Member for
19 years 5 monthsRE: EVMS and P3
Hello,
If we are agreed for the relation of 3 variables is
BCWP = SPI x (BQ - ETC)
in my assumption that BCWS = BQ
ACWP = BCWS - ETC
So you have all these 3 variable in P3 Calculation.
Sorry if this comment cannot fulfill your query.
BR.
Praves