One way we overcame the problem of non-project/admin activities was to show the maximum units against the resources at a percentage less than 100% (e.g. 80%).
Each resources availability can either be determined from historical data (timesheets etc), or an agreed allowance for administrative/non project work agreed on by the Resource Managers.
In my experience resource allocation is much more of a problem between projects than it is within one project. It also requires that all of the work, not just project work be included in the master file of all workers. I do not think MS Project can handle this in many organizations.
MS Project will allow the creation of a "resource pool", to which projects may be linked. Below is an extract from MSP help:
"A resource pool allows you to share resources among multiple projects. Using a resource pool allows you to schedule resources work across projects, identify conflicts between assignments in different projects, and see how a resources time is used in multiple projects If you have people or equipment that work on tasks in multiple project files, you may want to use the resource pool to centralize resource information, such as resource name, calendar used, resource units, and cost rate tables, making it easier to administer. Each project that uses resources from the resource pool is called a sharing file. You can use any other existing project file as a resource pool, but it is recommended that you create a new project file just for resource information to make it easiest to manage resource information and task assignments between sharing files and the resource pool."
This has the advantage of only having to create and maintain a single project file, rather than having to update each individual project files resources.
For further MSP Help on the subject, type "share" into the keyword box, then select "All about sharing resources" from the topic list.
Your basic question is what software would best suit your requirements. I believe you can use both MS Project and Primavera Software to attain your objectives based on the scenarios you’ve enumerated. Answering point by point your queries can be best answered if you already in the process of preparing your schedule.
You have posted your request for help in managing resources on an MS Project forum, but you say you would like advice on what software to use.
Two points you make about your multiple projects resourcing lead me to recommend either Primavera Project Planner (P3) or Primavera SureTrak (ST):
1) One of your projects uses resources in both day and night shifts P3 or ST handle up to 31 different base calendars, as well as unlimited resource calendar variants of the base calendars. They can also handle different shift calendars.
2) You are sharing resources across multiple projects.
P3 or ST can handle a group of Projects, called a Project Group, and member projects. These share resources, as well as coding and calendars.
You can plan each project separately, but report and analyse the resource usages overall in the Project group.
The key to managing this is the use of Activity Codes and Activity ID codes, especially the special Sub-Project Code (1st 2 characters of the Activity ID code used to identify which member project the activity belongs to).
In P3 you can code the resources hierarchically so that they can be generic or particular people.
eg, ENG* would capture all resources beginning ENG, while ENGJim could be a particular engineer named Jim. Jim would also be grouped in the wildcard resource ENG*
Spider Project is most functional and powerful professional project management software.
The first SP version was launched in 1993 and since then it has been constantly improved. Today is used in 34 countries though most Spider Project customers are in Russia. Spider Project offers numerous unique functional features and is the only PM software that optimizes resource, cost, and material constrained schedules and budgets for projects and portfolios.
The unique features of Spider Project include Quantity Based Scheduling, Conditional Scheduling, Skill Scheduling, Optimal Resource, Cost and Material Leveling, Resource Critical Path Calculation, Cash and Material Flows Calculation and Management, Trend Analysis, Advanced Risk Simulation and Analysis, Calculation of Success Probability Trends, Calculation and Management of required Project Time and Cost Buffers, Application of Corporate Norms, Management of many Parallel Budgets, Multiple WBS and many others.
Spider Project was and is used for management of many large scale programs in Russia, including $51bln construction program for 2014 Winter Olympic Games preparation.
The application areas where Spider Project is successfully used include Aerospace, Banking, Construction, Defense, Energy, Engineering, Infrastructure, Manufacturing, Metallurgy, Mining, Oil & Gas, Railways, Retail, Shipbuilding, Software Development, Telecommunications, Utilities, etc.
P6-Auditor - Display information from Primavera P6 audit tables in a user-friendly format
Unifier-Archiver - Extract and archive important documents and attachments from Primavera Unifier
Unifier-Loader - Load data into and out of Unifier via Excel
PCM-Loader - Import data into Primavera Contract Management with flexible and secure, template-driven Excel spreadsheets
PCM-Archiver - Extract and archive important documents and attachments from Primavera Contract Management
PCM-Unifier Migrator - Automatically transfer live and historical data from Primavera Contract Management to Primavera Unifier with ease
Create Radically Better Construction Schedules with ALICE Technologies
Use the power of AI to create construction schedules that reduce risk while cutting costs and build time. With ALICE, develop the ideal schedule during preconstruction -- or recover projects that are off schedule and over budget.
One way we overcame the problem of non-project/admin activities was to show the maximum units against the resources at a percentage less than 100% (e.g. 80%).
Each resources availability can either be determined from historical data (timesheets etc), or an agreed allowance for administrative/non project work agreed on by the Resource Managers.
In my experience resource allocation is much more of a problem between projects than it is within one project. It also requires that all of the work, not just project work be included in the master file of all workers. I do not think MS Project can handle this in many organizations.
Bob Youker Bethesda Md.
MS Project will allow the creation of a "resource pool", to which projects may be linked. Below is an extract from MSP help:
"A resource pool allows you to share resources among multiple projects. Using a resource pool allows you to schedule resources work across projects, identify conflicts between assignments in different projects, and see how a resources time is used in multiple projects If you have people or equipment that work on tasks in multiple project files, you may want to use the resource pool to centralize resource information, such as resource name, calendar used, resource units, and cost rate tables, making it easier to administer. Each project that uses resources from the resource pool is called a sharing file. You can use any other existing project file as a resource pool, but it is recommended that you create a new project file just for resource information to make it easiest to manage resource information and task assignments between sharing files and the resource pool."
This has the advantage of only having to create and maintain a single project file, rather than having to update each individual project files resources.
For further MSP Help on the subject, type "share" into the keyword box, then select "All about sharing resources" from the topic list.
I have used a product called e-PSO which seems to fit your requirement.
Its a workflow/web based product which can be found at www.e-pso.co.uk or please e-mail me for more information on [email protected]
Best regards
Katy
Your basic question is what software would best suit your requirements. I believe you can use both MS Project and Primavera Software to attain your objectives based on the scenarios you’ve enumerated. Answering point by point your queries can be best answered if you already in the process of preparing your schedule.
If you have questions, feel free to email me.
You have posted your request for help in managing resources on an MS Project forum, but you say you would like advice on what software to use.
Two points you make about your multiple projects resourcing lead me to recommend either Primavera Project Planner (P3) or Primavera SureTrak (ST):
1) One of your projects uses resources in both day and night shifts P3 or ST handle up to 31 different base calendars, as well as unlimited resource calendar variants of the base calendars. They can also handle different shift calendars.
2) You are sharing resources across multiple projects.
P3 or ST can handle a group of Projects, called a Project Group, and member projects. These share resources, as well as coding and calendars.
You can plan each project separately, but report and analyse the resource usages overall in the Project group.
The key to managing this is the use of Activity Codes and Activity ID codes, especially the special Sub-Project Code (1st 2 characters of the Activity ID code used to identify which member project the activity belongs to).
In P3 you can code the resources hierarchically so that they can be generic or particular people.
eg, ENG* would capture all resources beginning ENG, while ENGJim could be a particular engineer named Jim. Jim would also be grouped in the wildcard resource ENG*
Hope this helps.